wheel My order
Home / Insights /

Cadillac vs Toyota Reliability

In our inspections, Toyota’s average condition stays above the “decent” threshold to around 146k miles, versus 76k for Cadillac.

Based on 68 Cadillacs and 778 Toyotas. “Decent” means a condition score of 55/100.

vs
Head to head
CadillacToyota
Cars inspected68778
Average condition55/10063/100
In good shape (60+/100)38%57%
Holds up to (avg dips below decent)~76k mi~146k mi
Repainted or replaced panel68%77%
Structural repair found4%4%
Fault codes recently cleared22%18%

Green = the better number of the pair. Condition reflects the mix of cars that came to us — age, price, model — so treat small gaps as a tie.

How they score
Excellent 16% Good 22% Mediocre 34% Poor 28%
Excellent 29% Good 28% Mediocre 24% Poor 19%
How long do they stay good?
Good cars by mileage
▬ Cadillac▬ Toyota▬ all cars
0 25 50 75 100 Cadillac, 0–20k mi: 67%, drawn from the nearby bands (10 cars in this band)Cadillac, 20–40k mi: 65%, drawn from the nearby bands (8 cars in this band)Cadillac, 40–60k mi: 49%, drawn from the nearby bands (6 cars in this band)Cadillac, 60–80k mi: 37%, drawn from the nearby bands (12 cars in this band)Cadillac, 80–100k mi: 30%, drawn from the nearby bands (11 cars in this band)Cadillac, 100–120k mi: 13%, drawn from the nearby bands (10 cars in this band) Toyota, 0–20k mi: 100% in good shape (25 cars)Toyota, 20–40k mi: 90% in good shape (62 cars)Toyota, 40–60k mi: 81% in good shape (57 cars)Toyota, 60–80k mi: 85% in good shape (99 cars)Toyota, 80–100k mi: 59% in good shape (74 cars)Toyota, 100–120k mi: 61% in good shape (111 cars)Toyota, 120–140k mi: 44% in good shape (87 cars)Toyota, 140–160k mi: 35% in good shape (94 cars)Toyota, 160–180k mi: 33% in good shape (66 cars)Toyota, 180–200k mi: 22% in good shape (36 cars)Toyota, 200–220k mi: 22% in good shape (23 cars) 40k 80k 120k 160k 200k mileage when we inspected it
Good cars by age
▬ Cadillac▬ Toyota▬ all cars
0 25 50 75 100 Cadillac, 1 years old: 84%, drawn from the nearby bands (6 cars this age)Cadillac, 3 years old: 64%, drawn from the nearby bands (5 cars this age)Cadillac, 4 years old: 49%, drawn from the nearby bands (5 cars this age)Cadillac, 5 years old: 56%, drawn from the nearby bands (5 cars this age)Cadillac, 9 years old: 34%, drawn from the nearby bands (7 cars this age)Cadillac, 10 years old: 14%, drawn from the nearby bands (7 cars this age)Cadillac, 12 years old: 24%, drawn from the nearby bands (6 cars this age) Toyota, 1 years old: 100% in good shape (20 cars)Toyota, 2 years old: 95% in good shape (38 cars)Toyota, 3 years old: 89% in good shape (27 cars)Toyota, 4 years old: 94% in good shape (31 cars)Toyota, 5 years old: 89% in good shape (44 cars)Toyota, 6 years old: 78% in good shape (41 cars)Toyota, 7 years old: 72% in good shape (47 cars)Toyota, 8 years old: 75% in good shape (44 cars)Toyota, 9 years old: 56% in good shape (59 cars)Toyota, 10 years old: 68% in good shape (53 cars)Toyota, 11 years old: 63% in good shape (38 cars)Toyota, 12 years old: 42% in good shape (45 cars)Toyota, 13 years old: 33% in good shape (57 cars)Toyota, 14 years old: 39% in good shape (41 cars)Toyota, 15 years old: 32% in good shape (44 cars)Toyota, 16 years old: 27% in good shape (30 cars) 2y 4y 6y 8y 10y 12y 14y 16y vehicle age when we inspected it

Share in good shape (scoring 60+/100) by mileage and by age when we inspected them (each dot ≥5 cars; a band under 20 cars follows the nearby bands, so a run above the all-cars line stays above it, and a band of 20 or more uses the rate we measured; where a band has too few cars, the line follows the trend between the bands on either side; rolled-back odometers excluded from the mileage curve). Dashed grey = all cars we check.

Most common faults
Fuel trim out of range · Engine
56%
Oil leaks · Engine
51%
Active error codes · Electronic equipment
41%
Tires condition & wear · Brakes and tires
35%
Dirty or low engine oil · Engine
22%
Oil leaks · Engine
47%
Tires condition & wear · Brakes and tires
36%
Active error codes · Electronic equipment
26%
Fuel trim out of range · Engine
21%
Tire pressure monitoring system · Brakes and tires
20%
Trajectory by generation
Cadillac

Not enough Cadillacs at the 5–10 year checkpoint yet to draw a generation trend.

Toyota ▲ Newer Toyotas are holding up better 40% 60% 80% 2012–14: 69% in good shape (age-adjusted; 59 cars, raw 64%) 69 2015–17: 74% in good shape (age-adjusted; 121 cars, raw 70%) 74 2018–20: 74% in good shape (age-adjusted; 77 cars, raw 79%) 74 2021+: 77% in good shape (age-adjusted; 20 cars, raw 90%) 77 2009–11 2012–14 2015–17 2018–20 2021+

Share in good shape when inspected at the same age (5–10 years, age-adjusted), by model-year generation; dashed = all-brand average. All brands →

FAQ
?
Which is more reliable, Cadillac or Toyota?
In our inspections, Toyota’s average condition stays above the “decent” threshold to around 146k miles, versus 76k for Cadillac.
?
What are the most common problems with used Cadillacs and Toyotas?
On Cadillacs we flag fuel trim out of range (56%), oil leaks (51%), active error codes (41%). On Toyotas: oil leaks (47%), tires condition & wear (36%), active error codes (26%).
?
How many Cadillac and Toyota vehicles have you inspected?
68 Cadillacs and 778 Toyotas — 846 real pre-purchase inspections. Updated Nov 16, 2026.
?
How long do Cadillac and Toyota stay in decent condition?
In our data, decent is a 55/100 score. The average Cadillac dips below it around 76k mi; Toyota around 146k mi. Individual cars vary — get the one you’re buying inspected.
Buying a used Cadillac or Toyota? Get a pre-purchase inspection before you pay.
Book an inspection

Based on 846 inspections · updated Nov 16, 2026